Catherine Xavier-Lehnsherr thought that she was a rather mature, sensible girl. She never argued with her parents over her curfew. She saved up her birthday money to buy herself a gaming laptop. She even didn’t get goaded into a fight by William Stryker, Westchester Prep’s biggest asshole, when he said that girls were stupid.

 

And then she developed a crush on the wrong person: one of her best friends.


Written for dreamshadow's Friends Don't Challenge.


Rating and Advisories (required): Teen Audiences (None)
Content Warnings (optional): None

Genre: AU, Fluff, Romance

Tropes: Detention, Established Relationship, Family, Friends to Lovers, Friendship, Idiots in love, Modern AU, Mutual Pining, Sarcastic Devotee, School, Vitriolic Best Friends

Story Type: Challenge Entry, Novella (under 50,000 words)
Completed · Published: 02 May 2023 · Updated: 23 Aug 2024 · Words: 36160 · Chapters: 14 · Reviews: 47 · Likes: 10 · Reads: 1183

Series: None

Hi everyone! Hope you enjoy! I'm doing something a little different with these two, and I hope it works out.




1. The Catapult Incident by lostrobin (2576 words) · 8 Reviews · 4 likes

The one in which Alex's stupid face gets Catherine stuck in detention.


2. The Breakfast Incident by lostrobin (2692 words) · 6 Reviews · 1 likes

The one in which Emma actually drives somewhere.


3. The Pep Rally Incident by lostrobin (1616 words) · 6 Reviews · 0 likes

The one in which Sean convinces Catherine to do something.


4. The Football Incident by lostrobin (3024 words) · 4 Reviews · 1 likes

The one in which Charles flees to the sticky safety of Flying Scoops.


5. The Hair Incident by lostrobin (1875 words) · 4 Reviews · 1 likes

The one in which Catherine forgets something.


6. The Open House Incident by lostrobin (3115 words) · 4 Reviews · 1 likes

The one in which Catherine really wants a cookie.


7. The Stupid Plan Incident by lostrobin (3128 words) · 4 Reviews · 1 likes

The one in which Sean has a stupid idea and loses his fries.


8. The Dress Incident by lostrobin (2725 words) · 3 Reviews · 0 likes

The one in which Erik flees the mansion.


9. The Birthday Incident by lostrobin (3106 words) · 2 Reviews · 0 likes

The one in which Scott attempts to flirt.


10. The Homecoming Incident by lostrobin (3939 words) · 2 Reviews · 0 likes

The one in which Alex wants to say something.


11. The Quarry Incident by lostrobin (2739 words) · 2 Reviews · 0 likes

The one in which Excalibur is accidentally stabby.


12. The Witchfire Incident by lostrobin (3132 words) · 1 Reviews · 1 likes

The one in which Catherine and Alex ask some questions.


13. The Debate Incident by lostrobin (2255 words) · 1 Reviews · 0 likes

The one in which Scott actually makes sense.


14. The Catapult Incident (Take Two) by lostrobin (238 words) · 0 Reviews · 0 likes

The one in which Alex's stupid face gets Catherine stuck in detention (again).